A narrative essay paragraph has to be compelling and written like a story for it to draw attention of readers. There would be many instances when you start off with a well written paragraph and end up writing poor support paragraphs. This can be avoided if you follow some basic techniques and be consistent throughout your essay.
Write a narrative essay format that highlights the thesis statement first. In other words when you write the introduction, you have the basis to develop it the way you want. You can start by noting down points. Once you have them, you sit on a brainstorming session and add to those points. You might get ideas for some more to be added as you go through this exercise. Work on those, and you would know how to be consistent through all the paragraphs.
As you choose your narrative essay topics, keep in mind their relevance to recent events. The easiest way to do this is to choose a topic that connects your experience with the place or location. For example, you could write about an event that took place in school or college and include its description. It would take some time for you to gather relevant information about the institution, but you have to remember this would be of great interest to many readers. You would have developed compelling content that would benefit others.
You can opt to follow a particular narrative essay example you like. It could be due a variety of reasons including style of writing, formatting, usage of quotations, or just the way the essay is structured. If you liked the essay when you first read it, try and reason out why you liked it. Also, many other readers would have appreciated the way the narrative essay sample was written. You can then adapt the techniques used to write your own essay. You need to maintain your own individual writing style and try to make it unique.
Prepare a narrative essay outline for each paragraph. Work on each sentence and try to connect it to the thesis statement. You could do this by logically using the points you noted down during the brainstorming session and link them one after another to the thesis statement. This would test your writing skills. The story has to flow without irrelevant interruptions or breaks from the story.
Test each paragraph for relevance. This is the tough part. Isolate each paragraph and try to write about a particular event within the main event. For example, if you were writing about the school annual day, the second paragraph could be a write-up on your school. Do not try to connect each paragraph at this stage. Just write about your school. Follow the logic you used when noting down the points relevant to the essay. You will find ample evidence that relevance is generated quite naturally as you write. You can always make some changes to improve the flow of language later on.
These are simple but very powerful techniques which when used correctly can help you write great narrative essay paragraphs.